Labor stops short of outlawing brutal slaughter

Labor stops short of outlawing brutal slaughter

11 October 2011 Have your say

On Tuesday October 11, Labor was presented with a critical opportunity to spare millions of animals an agonising death by mandating that exported animals be stunned unconscious at slaughter.

Encouraged by letters, e-mails and phone calls of support from over 60,000 caring Australians, Labor MPs and Senators were under no illusions as to public expectations, and that there was no reasonable excuse not to pass the motion before caucus submitted by MP Tony Zappia.

Despite appeals from some caring Labor MPs during caucus debate, the motion was considerably weakened from 'mandating' stunning to 'encouraging' stunning — meaning that animals will continue to be exported and have their throats cut while fully conscious in foreign abattoirs.

New legislation, new hope

Unsatisfied with Labor's disappointing position, staunch opponent of the live trade independent MP Andrew Wilkie announced his intention to submit new legislation to parliament requiring that if the live export industry is to continue for the time being, it must include animal welfare safeguards and specifically afford animals the most basic protection from un-stunned slaughter.

This new legislation comes off the back of ongoing efforts by Wilkie to legislate a total phase out of the inherently cruel live trade — a position the Tasmanian MP still upholds.

"I held out hope that the Caucus would show genuine consideration for animal welfare and the overwhelming public pressure for reform, and was shocked to learn that stunning is considered an option rather than a necessity.

"The shocking animal cruelty revealed by 4 Corners some months ago provided an historic opportunity to finally do something about Australia’s barbaric live animal export industry. We must seize the moment for the sake of the animals and out of respect for public opinion." — Andrew Wilkie in a press release on Tuesday.

What you can do

Both the Coalition and Labor's outdated policies to support the interests of the live export industry are clearly at odds with the interests of animals and the Australian public. Please send your MP a reminder that while caring Australians want an end to live export, the very least we should be able to expect from our elected representatives is to ensure that animals born into Australian care are spared from the horrors of fully conscious slaughter. Click here to send an instant message now, or use the form below to find the contact details of your representative:

Find your federal MP:

State:

Suburb:



Post a commentYour Say: 2370 comments

Sort by Most Recent or Most liked
Val:Mv Ocean Shearer-bobby calves: Ban Live Exports Thursday, 29 December 2011 at 6:08am
I have been busy now talking and handing out flyers to people in the street.I feel sorry for the pollies as some people are really rude and don't care about Live Exports.One woman wasn't sure about signing my petition,the one i had from Animals Australia and opened my letter i had before i could stop her.I won't elaborate further.At least i know now the majority of people are against Live Exports.one lady even wanted to sign for her daughter but i said i don't know what to do in a situation like that.Did you get my petition AA.?
Show 1 reply
LW: Powerful words Sunday, 6 November 2011 at 3:24pm
When it comes to Animal Cruelty - thought these emotionally powerful words spoke volumes :
' Unseen they suffer. Unheard they cry. In agony they linger. In loneliness they die.'  Anonymous
Show 1 reply
sue- Adelaide: thanks Sunday, 6 November 2011 at 8:49am
thanks animals australia for changing a lot of peoples views on how we should treat animals  we all lived in blissful ignorance before , now we have to face the facts and we are all shell shocked.
Show 1 reply
Val: Greyhounds Friday, 4 November 2011 at 11:05pm
Take a minute to look up Greyhounds.I'll say no more.It made me cry.
Val Lyn White Brave Lady: Bobby calves Friday, 4 November 2011 at 6:04am
Have you heard our commercials.Drink such and such milk that is the way the locals like it.Load of B---S----. we should buy anything but dairy.Those poor little bobby calves.We have to fight for them.I will try soy soon or whatever.My fur person is asleep.Gee it's quiet.My trouble is i am shy and i hate going out in public and showing people the truth.We all know What the truth is on here.
Show 11 replies
Val Lyn White Brave Lady: Message to people Friday, 4 November 2011 at 5:44am
Lyn White should be made Australian of the year.I am not trying to take on the system. I see our animals suffering and i don't know what to do.There is a movie out about taking on the system i heard.I am just trying to help after Four Corners and the cruelty Lyn exposed.Please everyone vote for Lyn as i could not go into an abbattoir.RIP dear animals.We all get Karma.Willie my cat is around He passed awhile back.Dear boy.See you one day Willie.Your name sake believes in karma.too.He is one of my favorites Willie Nelson.I named my cat after him.
Show 2 replies
Lili -Adelaide: Australian Of the Year 2012 Thursday, 3 November 2011 at 10:16pm
Great news all , Lynn White has made the finalist list on
SA  .... Australian of The Year- Animal Welfare Activist.

Congratulations Lynn White.......you deserve it !
Congratulations Animals Australia............you deserve it !
Show 5 replies
Val: The circus Thursday, 3 November 2011 at 8:44pm
I just heard where someone in the circus has died.I'm sorry.I was complaining only about the animals being all right in circuses.It is something i used to like the circus.In the country we did not have the bright lights.A circus was so exciting.I always think of the movie Trapeze.The old movies were good.I expect The RSPCA will check anyway.We can ask.I went to sleep sitting up before as i worry a lot at night.I miss my fur person too. The other fur person is still here and bossy just lke her mum Cindy.They were a lovely little family of cats my daughter had.I  think of all animals the same.They are all Family. The animals i mean.I am going to watch the 7Pm project.That is where i saw those enclosed sheep again on George Negus.I hope they ban it.Locking sheep up too close is wrong.
Magrit Falls: Stop the brutal slaughtering Thursday, 3 November 2011 at 1:20pm
Stop the brutal slaughtering.  The govenment has a lot to answer for.  Absolutly disgraceful
Lili -Adelaide: Retired Race Horses Thursday, 3 November 2011 at 10:59am
Perhaps if  we organised ourselves, we could write letters to the appropriate racing bodies, Gail Waterhouse,Bart Cummings and others and suggest that with every bet the bookies, put $1 or 1 %, towards the welfare of the horses who retire from racing and if they are not going to be used for breeding.
A sanctuary for retired race horses.............instead of the knackery.
I wonder what the racing dynasty like Waterhouse and Cummings would say?
It could be worth a try.
Show 3 replies
Sally: Melbourne Cup Thursday, 3 November 2011 at 8:34am
Sure the Melbourne Cup is Aussie culture, we have a big day out, dress up, have a big booze up etc. etc. but essentially it is about big money and horses being pushed to their limits...sometimes dying...and what for?? a few big punters greedy for a few extra $$$$$...not worth the cruelty within this industry.!!!
V: Meydan Racetrack Dubai Wednesday, 2 November 2011 at 7:32pm
The biggest racetrack in Dubai is going to be built even though they have massive debt.What will happen to all the beautiful horses.I get upset but there is nothing i can do.Th horses will be treated terrible when they have finished racing them.Oh well i never stop complaining.Look up The biggest racetrack in Dubai and you will see what i am on about.Humans need to look after horses like Doris Day the singer does.I am so sorry she has to pick up the pieces .Her Website shows what she does.Just look up doris day.
Show 2 replies
Rosie: Punters bet big Wednesday, 2 November 2011 at 6:56pm
The Melbourne Cup punters waged $550mill. What a waste. Can you imagine what good could be done for animal welfare not only in Australia but around the world with that obscene amount of money.
Yes Victoria, If every animal lover donated $18 per month to Animals Australia, Lyn White could expose many atrocities to animals on TV every week to remind the voting public & the government what is happening out there under their watch.
I donate monthly to Animals Australia, WSPA & Voiceless. It makes me feel good. This forum also makes me feel I am not alone in my views for animal rights.
Thank you all
Show 1 reply
V: Dubai Wednesday, 2 November 2011 at 4:49pm
Smeone can wiin a trip for two to Dubai if they text or sms channel 7 in perth now.The Question is Where is the racecourse which hosts the Dubai World cup.If anyone here wins look after our sheep in dubai.I have not got a sms or text.
Victoria P: Help make Animals Aus voice louder Wednesday, 2 November 2011 at 4:48pm
We are all hopping mad with frustration about this cruelty to our stock, so my suggestion has been, to perhaps give some thought to being a regular donar to Animals Aus - it need only be a small donation - but many of us each contributing a little will surely help. It appears the ONLY TIME POLITICIANS ACT is when it is brought home to them so graphically they cannot ignore it - and the outrage it causes to people like us. I am simply a member of AA, nothing more, and got to thinking after seeing much frustration in these posts - I am happy for my $$$ to fund more trips by Lynn White and her fellow investigators, to constantly show what is happening in these hell houses (abottoirs).
The exporters will not allow AA on board these "luxury" ships, but Lynn is very experienced and will always find a way to expose these atrocities. Also more resources will enable Animals to show more TV ads -  making it difficult for pollies to ignore what we are so angry about.   It need only be a few $$$$ each month - and I am sure many of us are quite happy to do this - perhaps the best way we can fight for these animals we are so passionate about.
If these animals bask in such "luxury" on these live export ships, why do they not proudly welcome RSPCA/AA aboard to check them out? Why do so many animals die? Surely that is not good economics? How many deaths are regarded as "acceptable."   Some food for thought.
Val-Bobby Calves: Human and animal experiments Tuesday, 1 November 2011 at 9:56pm
Because of things i have seen on here i now remember strange things i have seen.If you think there is only animal experiments look up experiments on humans.Terrible There is heaps of cruel things.just put in HUMAN EXPERIMENTS.it also applies to animals.Awful world isn't it sometimes.
Val: Another Cup Tuesday, 1 November 2011 at 2:24pm
I was told Americaine would win but i don't bet.I hope the horse who won has a long and healthy life.Dear Horses.Doris Day looks after abandoned horses and lots of other animals as well.Her website DORIS DAY is worth looking at.I put a song for my cat on the radio tonight by Doris day.on CurtinFM.
Show 1 reply
Val-Bright Eyes: Circuses Tuesday, 1 November 2011 at 1:48pm
I wonder do they still have trained animals in circuses where they are not treated well.I had to say this when i was young in the country at circuses there was a tent like a sideshow.I went in once and saw all these deformed sheep and sheep with six legs.I went out and was scared.I never went back for another look.I wonder what they gave the sheep to look like that.So sad.The lady from my lovely little cats refuge is sending me a photo of the cat i fell for.He has a home now.He's lovely.A ginger boy.My other cat is still here(the Boss) of me.II will let you know about the circus here after.They do have a dog pushing a pram.What next.Anyway i must go and seee to baby,my cat,or the boss.
Val-Bright Eyes: Horses are beautiful Tuesday, 1 November 2011 at 9:34am
I wonder why all these people bet on an animal that is flogged all the way around a racetrack.I used to go to the races and was bored stiff.I was under the impression the horses were kept ok by the owners.We are all guilty of it.Ignoring cruelty forever to animals is dreadful.Humans can think and talk for themselves.Animals cant.I will go and shop today and wear my WSPA band and Telethon band.I am not great to look at but animals like my boss,my cat are.Oh and my RSPCA brooch too to let people know where to put there money.With the animals.BAN LIVE EXPORTS MS GILLARD NOW PLEASE>
Lori: Why Are People So Unkind Monday, 31 October 2011 at 7:07pm
I am tired of seeing and hearing about animal cruelty. When will it stop. If you need to eat them, wear them, ride them, race them, farm them, experiment on them or catch them, do it humanly. These poor creatures have no voice. If these animals were your family pet you would be charged along with a jail sentence.
There is no right way to send animals overseas, for many weeks in ships, only to torture them at their final destination. This year the government has provided $85 million in financial backing for the live export trade. They are not listening to the people, never have - never will!
Show 3 replies
« Older comments
Post a message Your name:
Message title:
Your message:


By posting a comment here you agree to the community guidelines.
Post Message
JOIN Animals Australia TAKE ACTION! Donate Now!
Upcoming Events

Registered Charity No. A0020071Z

Print Page | Privacy Policy | RSS | Sitemap | Contact Us