PRESS RELEASE: Live sheep export challenged in Federal Court


14 June, 2018


Animals Australia will today appear in the first hearing of an unprecedented application in the Federal Court of Australia to challenge the legality of a live sheep export permit.

The challenge relates to an Emanuel Exports shipment of 58,000 sheep that departed Fremantle for the Middle East last week on the live export vessel, the Al Messilah. The month of June is the official start of the Middle East summer where the risks of sheep suffering and dying on vessels from heat stress during the northern-hemisphere summer are well documented.

"We believe the granting of this export permit by the Department of Agriculture was unlawful and we will be seeking an urgent Federal Court declaration to this effect," said Legal Counsel for Animals Australia, Shatha Hamade.

Under Australian law, an export permit for livestock may only be granted if certain conditions are met. These conditions include that the Secretary for the Department of Agriculture, or his delegate, be satisfied that the health, welfare and physical needs of the sheep will be met and maintained on an export voyage; and that thetravel arrangements for the livestock will be adequate for their health and welfare.

"This export permit was granted despite animal health and welfare experts, including the Australian Veterinary Association, recommending sheep shipments to the Middle East during the summer period should not continue, due to the foreseeable and unavoidable welfare repercussions."

"Animals Australia's position is that, in light of the conditions required to be met, it is impossible to understand how any decision-maker acting reasonably could have arrived at the decision to approve this export permit."

"The extensive science and data from the past two decades of shipping sheep during the extreme heat and humidity of a northern summer speak to the inevitable distress and suffering that these animals will endure."

A key recommendation from the McCarthy Review is that the heat stress risk assessment model be changed from one that is 'mortality based' to one that is 'animal welfare based'. This has not been implemented — yet export permits continue to be granted.

"The Turnbull government has said that its policy is that the trade will continue during the northern summer. But whether this export permit was lawfully granted will now be a matter for the Federal Court to decide," said Ms Hamade.

Animals Australia's legal team is represented by barristers Dan Star QC, Nick Wood and Jim Hartley.


The hearing is at 2:15pm on the afternoon of 14 June 2018) at the Owen Dixon Commonwealth Law Courts Building, 305 William Street, Melbourne. Animals Australia's Director of Strategy, Lyn White & Legal Counsel, Shatha Hamade, will be available to speak to media outside the Court at 1:50pm.



Want to stay informed?

If you're keen to have your finger on the pulse of animal protection in Australia, we invite you to become an Animals Australia Insider. As an insider, we’ll send you time-sensitive press releases and other important announcements that we publish in between our scheduled e-updates.

Become an Animals Australia Insider

Love animals? Subscribe and help end animal abuse:
I've read and accept the privacy policy
Like Animals Australia On Facebook